Robert Gott






Scribe Publications, 2004
Reviewed by Sunnie Gill

It’s 1942 and Australians are beginning to feel the full effects of the war. The Japanese are advancing ever further south and in Europe the battle of Stalingrad is raging. Food rationing is coming into effect in Australia.

Enter William Power, founder of the Power Players, a third rate theatre group which is touring country Queenslander bringing culture and Shakespeare (or a form of it) to the country hicks.

Power’s troupe is a rag tag bunch of misfits. There’s Tibald Canty, the gourmet cook, a good actor but limited by his 300lb size; the improbably named Arthur Rank who lost an arm in an accident with a threshing machine some years earlier; Adrian Baden is an openly gay man who is ineligible for military service by virtue of his flat feet, and then there’s Kevin Skakel, an appallingly bad actor with a club foot, who is the only male in the troupe willing to wear women’s clothes for his art. Bill Henty is blind in one eye, Walter Sunder is sixty-five years old and ready for retirement, and then there’s the “star” Annie Hudson, who looks like Greer Garson in certain lights and is known as the girl in the Colgate and Tampax ads you find in magazines.

Not a group of actors truly worthy of Will’s talent -- according to Will, anyway. Will is a man with a superiority complex. No one is as smart, as talented or as insightful as Will. From the lofty heights of his intellect, he looks down on all lesser mortals. His current project is to bring a “challenging new take” on Titus Andronicus to the unsuspecting populace of Maryborough in Queensland. But are they ready for Titus Andronicus minus the title character and with the males in the troupe wearing only posing pouches?

GOOD MURDER opens with the troupe’s arrival in Maryborough. They’ve struck a deal with the owner of a local hotel. In return for discount accommodation, Tibald will act as chef and the troupe will wait tables. While Will is working on the script for Titus Andronicus, one of the young women of the town, Polly Drummond makes a beeline for him. Will takes this attention as his due. After all, is he not incredibly good looking, talented and smart? Well, no, actually, but Will has an amazing capacity for self-delusion.

The day after Will spends the evening with Polly and has an unfortunate encounter with her demented mother, Polly disappears. Her body is discovered five days later floating in the water tower – the town’s major water supply. Much to his horror, Will realises that as the last known person to see Polly alive, he’s the main suspect in her death. He decides to put the record straight and investigate, but his every step sinks him deeper in to the mire as more deaths occur.

GOOD MURDER is not a book without flaws. The use of language and attitudes seem to be more a reflection of contemporary society than that of 1942. The book itself is at times almost Shakespearean in its action and drama, and some of the situations are just a little contrived. Will’s penchant for getting things wrong is just a little too consistent to keep the reader guessing much. And his lack of insight into those around him becomes a little predictable.

However, despite this, I found myself warming to Will and liking him for his ineptitude and complete lack of insight into himself and others. The cast of characters are colourful and entertaining, and the author has a flair for description that paints comprehensive mental images. The opening paragraph of the book is a fine example of this:
”The water tower in Maryborough sat on the corner of Adelaide and Anne Streets. It held one million gallons of water and, for two weeks in August 1942, it also held the body of a 24-year-old woman named Polly Drummond. Afterwards it was impossible not to be appalled by the realisation that each time we drank a cup of tea we were imbibing Polly Drummond, and that each time we took a bath we were splashing ourselves with Polly Drummond. As she slowly dissolved up there, bloating and exuding the corrupt gases and liquids of the dead, we in the town strained her through our teeth, gargled her, washed our hair with her, and imbedded her in the very clothes we wore.”

I don’t know if Robert Gott is planning on making the character of Will Power into an ongoing series. If he is, then I have doubts about whether the idea is sustainable. As a one off book, though, GOOD MURDER is a jolly good read and a lot of fun.

March 2006

home      back

All cover art used at Reviewer's Choice Reviews is copyrighted by the respective publisher. All reviews and articles found at Reviewer's Choice Reviews are the sole property of the contributor and are copyrighted by the same.